Posted By Michael Magan Share

After the suspicious sinking on March 26 of the South Korean corvette Cheonan in the Yellow Sea, an investigation was conducted by South Korea with assistance from the United States, Britain, Sweden, and Australia to determine the cause. The results are expected to be officially announced this week. It will come as little surprise that a North Korean torpedo attack will be found responsible for the death of 46 South Korean sailors.

Since 2008, North Korea has stepped up this kind of hostile activity. It has conducted more nuclear tests, launched at least 12 missiles and rockets, increased its arms trade with regimes like Iran, Republic of Congo, Syria and Burma, and increased its intelligence activities against South Korea. Even in the midst of this stepped-up bellicosity, the sinking of the naval ship Cheonan is perhaps the most blatant provocation against South Korea in the past two decades, and an act of war under international law. Ironically the DPRK continues to advocate publicly for the reunification of the Korean peninsula - while it attacks its own relatives.

It is not clear what drives North Korea's actions. Many speculate the regime does this to distract the international community during a volatile time of a leadership succession, or to divert the attention of its own oppressed citizens who live on less than 1700 calories a day, many of whom resort to grazing in local parks for edible grasses (which I saw firsthand during a visit to Pyongyang). The country as a whole continues to face the potential of another famine. Callous hardliners remain steadfast in tormenting their own people only for the sake of maintaining the regime's monopoly on power.

How will the international community react? Thus far, the U.S. has depended largely on the six-party talks to find a peaceful resolution to security concerns with North Korea, and during the past three years of South Korean President Lee Myung-Bak's administration, Seoul only took a reactive stance against North Korea's aggressions and left Kim Jong Il  in the driver's seat. Similarly in this instance, South Korea, the U.S. and the international community look likely to react by taking the sinking of the Cheonan to the U.N. Security Council and seeking greater sanctions against North Korea.

UNSC sanctions and condemnation are a necessary but not sufficient step. Now is the time for both South Korea and the United States to step up and define a firm policy towards North Korea. The Lee administration needs to stop pursuing a reactive policy and firmly declare its position towards the North. South Korea should preempt another North Korean provocation by defining new rules of engagement such that if North Korea seeks reunification or economic growth, it must adhere to an international framework with clear conditions and benchmarks. The burden of compliance must be put on the North. 

Next week, Seoul will be meeting with delegations from the United States and China.  During these meetings, South Korea should take the initiative to seek support for its North Korea policy. The U.S., which still has major military facilities on the peninsula, should express its unwillingness to resume six-party talks until the North demonstrates that it is meeting the clearly defined benchmarks set forth from the South Korean administration. Until North Korea starts adhering to South Korean and international standards, it should be put back on the United States list as a state sponsor of terror.  The U.S. should also press China, which is seeking an FTA with South Korea, to declare its support for Seoul's policy and not succumb to North Korea's manipulative appeals for continued aid. 

As long as China remains ambivalent in its reaction to North Korea's aggressive behaviour, it is demonstrating a continued interest in maintaining a divided peninsula that produces regional tension and instability. Without a clear strategy towards North Korea, we can expect more of North Korea's hostile actions.

JUNG YEON-JE/AFP/Getty Images

EXPLORE:NORTH KOREA
 
Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

SURESH SHETH

10:46 PM ET

May 20, 2010

US has no choice but to put up with North Korea

US does NOT have that kind of clout to stop putting up with North Korea with the rise of China. Let us not forget what happened in 1954 when Chinese soldiers flooded Korean peninsula.

Now China has even veto power to stop any UN action, thanks to Nixon-Kissinger giving China a UNSC seat with that power on a silver platter. Afterall China was a pariah country in the world just like today’s North Korea until that Nixon visit. All the east Asian and West European countries stayed away from China following the US lead until 1972 and embraced China after that Nixon visit.

North Korea can and will keep blackmailing US and its Western allies. Only thing US can do is just ignore North Korean shananigans and institute its own sanctions with its Western allies but without Chinese support.

US has to stop thinking that China is a US ally to contain North Korea when it has never been the case.

North Korea is China’s puppet while US tries to enlist China’s help against that very puppet. Everyone knows that Kim’s regime can not survive even a day without Chinese help but pretends that poor China can NOT control North Korea!

North Koreans are NOT geniuses who can invent ballistic missile or nuclear weapon technologies but everyone ignores China’s supply of those technologies to North Korea. Even Pakistan, another Chinese puppet, could NOT have dared to supply uranium enrichment technology to North Korea in return for China’s ballistic missile technology from North Korea if China would have objected to Pakistan.

But US and the world does not have any clout left to challenge China-Pakistan-North Korea nuclear axis proliferating nuclear weapon technology to the world.

US has nobody to blame but itself for the rise of China to challenge US.

 

N8RILEY

1:14 AM ET

May 22, 2010

A pitbull bites the owner is responsible

China owns this situation it called for calm on all sides so those 46 families should calm down china wants calm and the psychotic murderers in the north remain calm the outside world will do nothing we will water down resolutions so much it maybe more watered down then the last one. China worries about the refugees some keeping a maniac forcing famine and starvation makes sense Not! They would be economic migrants that how they get rid of them today. China has lost a lot of capital with the ROK and Japan maybe this time we will push the DPRK to the brink again and shove it over the edge! No one likes china well maybe Thomas L Friedman (Yeah they do thing so well it like if you can shoot anyone it make things easier)

 

RENEGADE

10:34 PM ET

May 22, 2010

sanctions on the DPRK

As a start, should the UNSC consider kicking North Korea out of the world cup in much the same way that UNSC 757 kicked Yugoslavia out of Euro 1992?

 

JOE7PACK

10:48 AM ET

May 28, 2010

North Korea - a sponsor of Terrorism

The Obama administration is pursuing a strategy against Al-Qada and the Taliban of denying them safe haven anywhere, enforced with purported superior stealth/smart weapons capability. This strategy makes perfect sense, turn the terrorists into targets and one of two things will happen; either they will give up their noble pursuits or they will find their way into paradise that much sooner. We need to target the leadership of all state sponsors of terrorism in the same way. Its just too bad we missed an opportunity when Kim Il took a train trip to China recently. That was a pretty easy target.

 

Shadow Government is a blog about U.S. foreign policy under the Obama administration, written by experienced policy makers from the loyal opposition and curated by Peter D. Feaver and William Inboden.

Read More